Toney, who scored his 27th goal of the season in the draw, claimed his side were denied several penalties against Al-Fayha.
The England international alleged that when he and his Al-Ahli teammates had attempted to talk to the referee, they were told to instead focus on the AFC Champions League.
‘I think the very big talking point was the two penalties, it is as clear as day,’ Toney said in a post-match interview. ‘I don’t know what more you want him to do, if you pick the ball up with two hands are you going to give a penalty or not?
‘When we tried to talk to the referee, he told us to ‘focus on the AFC [Champions League]. How can the referee say this? We are talking about now, and he is saying to focus on the AFC.
‘If you want me to go deeper, I can go deeper; it might get me into trouble, but I am a man that says it how it is. There are clear talking points with the referee, but his mind is elsewhere.
‘Throughout the season, it was a clear penalty, but now we get to the crunch time, and they change it.’
When asked who would benefit from the decisions, Toney laughed and replied: ‘We know who, who are we chasing?’ in a possible reference to Ronaldo.
Toney later doubled down on social media by sharing videos of three penalty appeals during the match and claimed ‘it is clear what is being influenced here’.
‘It’s actually crazy how you can miss things like this in crucial moments or chose to turn a blind eye. It’s clear what is being influenced here.
Also, with the referee telling us to concentrate on a different competition while VAR is going on is beyond me.
‘Add to that with the referee agreeing that the first one was a penalty in the 90+ minute like that’s going to help.
‘I am probably the bad guy for speaking some truths and pointing out questionable decisions or s*** refereeing.’
Toney’s team-mate Galeno added to the controversy, alleging the Saudi Pro League wants to ‘hand the trophy to one person’.
‘Hand over the trophy, that’s what they want, they want to knock us out of the championship by any means necessary, they want to hand the trophy to one person, a total lack of respect for our club,’ he wrote on social media.
Both players were backed by Al-Ahli, who urged the league to release recordings between the officials and their players during the match and demanded explanations over the refereeing decisions.